granola jar logo

1033 E Mount Pleasant Rd

Evansville, IN 47725

812 437 1899

5600 E Virginia Street

Evansville, IN 47715

812 401 8111

333 State Street Suite A

Newburgh, IN 47630

812 490 0060

Monday-Friday: 10AM-2PM


The Owner

Nealie Anthony, an Evansville native, started baking as a way to satisfy her boyfriend’s sweet tooth at only 16 years old. Baking soon became a passion for her, enough so that she moved to San Francisco to go to California Culinary Academy and become a pastry chef. She graduated in 2005 and moved back to the tri-state area with her husband to start a restaurant with her mother-in-law. Nealie is now a mother along side being the sole owner of the Granola Jar.


“What inspires me is my customers. I love chatting with them, hearing what they are liking at the cafe and just how their days are going.”


Our Start

The Granola Jar was founded in August of 2006 by Nealie, her husband Ryan, and her mother-in-law. “What came first the granola or the Granola Jar?” Making and inventing granola came first, and as Ryan’s mother, Ryan, and Nealie argued about what exactly they should call their fledgling expenditure, one day it finally came to Nealie in a stroke of genius. In the beginning, the business was breakfast-centric but has transformed into a lunch/catering business as it became clear that the location demanded more. Nealie had to learn everything as she went as the company evolved.

In 2012 Nealie and her husband Ryan took over the business fully and became the sole owners.